Skin conductance, emotion, and culture

a lit review

what is emotion?

theoretical - emotion (-al energy) and society

  • 1993 (collins) - here

    • talking about a market for ritual participation, shaping distribution of individual behavior
    • rational apportioning of work and ritual wrt EE
    • complex formulations at end of abstract I didn't understand
  • 2019 - EE, relational E, organizational E: a review

    • defines core concepts
    • broad selective review focusing on mechanisms
    • empirical findings, and ambiguities in conceptualization of E
    • "theorizing has outpaced empirical testing"
    • promising areas of empirical research
  • Berlant 2014 - Compassion: The culture and politics of an emotion (mentioned by recent Scheff) - in library

  • Thomas Scheff

  • 2004 - theory of self, emotion, and culture

    • substantiating the theory that: "a fundamental drive to maximize emotional energy"
    • explains self-consistency vs. creativy and change
    • details mechanisms underlying creation of new symbols and meanings

empirical - emotion and society (especially cross-cultural)

  • 2002 - emotion and culture: meta-analysis
    • 190 cross-cultural emotion studies before 2002
    • cross-cultural variation associated to subsistence mode, political system, values, and religiosity
    • but also to statistical artifacts etc
    • most of variance in "values"

what is EDA (synchrony) actually measuring?

EDA

  • 2007 - How emotion is made and measured, from human-computer interaction
  • Also this guide is sometimes cited
  • 2010 Modelling event-related skin conductance responses
    • I can't tell, but it looks like most of the variance is within-subjects, not between-subjects (Fig. 4)
    • mean peak latency is 4.3 seconds for fingers
  • 2015 - "Similarly, increased electro-dermal response happens in almost all emotions and may be a symptom of the motor preparation that is an integral part of the emotion episode (action tendency, Frijda, 1986), while decrease is found for all emotions in which passivity is the shared motivational state." Emotions: Methods of Assessment
  • 2020 (Nature) - SCR muted when watching the homeless for those with justificatory beliefs about inequality
  • 2019 - Latency of skin conductance
    • from abstract: "relies on response characteristics ... which were established more than four decades ago by using paper-pencil methods"
    • "The established response latency criteria were largely confirmed"
    • this study: "narrower and potential stimulus modality-specific latency criterion"
    • the classic studies: (e.g., Barry, 1990; Levinson & Edelberg, 1985; Lykken & Venables, 1971) == (Scoring criteria for response latency and habituation in electrodermal research; ibid: a critique; Direct measurement of skin conductance: A proposal for standardization)
    • it's about 2s but there is individual differences

EDA synchrony

micro-situational explanatory papers